Revision: On August 20, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas ruled in favor of Ryan LLC and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, halting the Federal Trade Commission’s nationwide non-compete ban, which was set to take effect on September 4. The Court determined that the ban exceeded the FTC’s legal authority and was arbitrary, capricious, and supported by flawed evidence. Consequently, the rule was invalidated.

If this decision stands, employers will not need to comply with the FTC’s non-compete ban or its associated notice requirements. However, the FTC is expected to appeal the decision, and other litigation on the rule is ongoing. For now, employers should remain informed as legal developments continue, particularly with the possibility of state-level regulations that could introduce additional complexities.

For now: Employers should remain informed as legal developments continue, particularly with the possibility of state-level regulations that could introduce additional complexities. Our firm stands ready to help you navigate these complexities.

—

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) recently made a significant ruling that directly impacts small and mid-sized businesses, especially in North Carolina. The ruling, passed with a slim majority of 3-2, has sparked debates and concerns among business owners regarding non-compete agreements. In light of this development, small business owners in North Carolina must understand the implications of the ruling and seek appropriate legal guidance.

The FTC ruling primarily addresses the issue of non-compete agreements, which have long been a common practice in various industries. These agreements restrict employees from working for competing businesses for a certain period after leaving their current employer. The FTC ruled and argued that non-compete agreements harm workers by reducing their ability to switch jobs for higher pay, reducing overall churn in the job market, and hurting the economy overall by limiting the ability of other businesses to hire needed employees. Several states, including California, previously had bans, influencing the ruling.

The FTC’s ruling raises questions about the validity and enforceability of such agreements, alongside the validity of the ruling itself.

Those against the ruling share several key rebuttals that North Carolina small business owners should be aware of:

1. Congressional Authority: One of the dissenting opinions against the ruling argues that the FTC does not have the authority to enact “legislative” rules, as its mandate is limited to procedural and administrative matters. This raises concerns about the ruling’s legality and suggests that it may face legal challenges.

2. Constitutional Issues: Critics of the ruling also contend that even if the FTC has the authority to make legislative rules, Congress has not clearly delegated such authority. Moreover, they argue that regulating contracts, including non-compete agreements, falls within the purview of state law rather than federal regulation. These constitutional concerns add complexity to the legal landscape surrounding non-compete agreements.

3. Legal Challenges: Given the contentious nature of the ruling, substantial legal challenges are expected in the coming days. The dissenting opinions highlight potential grounds for challenging the ruling, including claims of unconstitutional delegation of legislative authority and arbitrary decision-making.

Managing partner at SeiferFlatow, Mathew Flatow, summarized the following from the ruling:

“There are going to be challenges made to this ruling as Congress did not authorize the Commission to enact “legislative” rules, only procedural /administration rules. Contract regulation is a traditional area left to the states to regulate..”

In light of these developments, North Carolina small business owners must seek guidance from experienced business law attorneys. One such firm that can provide valuable assistance is SeiferFlatow, PLLC, led by business attorney Mathew Flatow. While there is currently no official guidance on how to navigate the FTC ruling, seeking advice from knowledgeable legal professionals is crucial for protecting your business’s interests.

At SeiferFlatow, PLLC, business attorneys understand the intricacies of non-compete agreements and other essential legal instruments such as non-solicitation agreements, non-disclosure agreements, and trade secret agreements. In light of the FTC ruling, they can offer tailored advice and assistance to help small business owners in North Carolina adapt to the changing regulatory landscape.

It’s important to note that while the FTC ruling may cast doubt on the enforceability of traditional non-compete agreements, small business owners can explore alternative strategies to protect their interests. Non-solicitation agreements, for example, restrict departing employees from soliciting clients or employees from their former employer. Similarly, non-disclosure agreements help safeguard confidential information and trade secrets.

By consulting with experienced business law attorneys like SeiferFlatow, PLLC, small business owners can gain clarity on their legal options and develop strategies to mitigate risks effectively. Given the uncertainty surrounding the FTC ruling, proactive measures are essential to safeguarding your business’s long-term viability and success.

While Chair Khan of the FTC has provided a rebuttal to the dissenting opinions, indicating a potential legal battle ahead, the outcome remains uncertain. Therefore, staying informed and seeking expert legal counsel is paramount for North Carolina small business owners.

In conclusion, the recent FTC ruling regarding non-compete agreements has significant implications for small businesses in North Carolina. To navigate these changes effectively and protect their interests, business owners should seek guidance from experienced business law attorneys like SeiferFlatow, PLLC. By exploring alternative legal instruments and developing proactive strategies, small businesses can adapt to the evolving regulatory landscape and thrive in a competitive market environment. Stay tuned for further developments, and remember to prioritize legal counsel to ensure the continued success of your business.